So, You're Turning 65—Now What?

Turning 65 should feel like a smooth transition into a new, more peaceful chapter of life. But for many Central Illinois residents, it often starts with something far less pleasant:

A mailbox stuffed with Medicare mailers.
Commercials that contradict each other.
Friends who insist their plan is “the right one.”
And the creeping worry: “What if I mess this up?”

Here’s the good news: You don’t need to figure this out alone — and you certainly don’t need to navigate it by sifting through sales pitches.

For more than 40 years, Sams/Hockaday & Associates has helped Decatur and surrounding communities understand Medicare clearly, avoid costly mistakes, and gain long-term confidence.

Below is a guide to help you start your turning‑65 journey the right way.

Do You Need to Enroll in Medicare at 65?

If you plan to retire around your 65th birthday, you’ll typically enroll in:

• Part A (hospital coverage) – premium‑free for most

• Part B (medical coverage) – monthly premium based on income

This combination works hand‑in‑hand with whatever supplemental coverage you choose next. Retiring at 65 makes this step relatively simple because your employer coverage ends, and Medicare becomes your primary insurance.

If You’re Working Past 65: This Is Where Things Get More Complicated (But Still Manageable with the Right Steps the First Time)

Many Central Illinois retirees plan to keep working. Some enjoy their job, others want to delay Social Security, and in those cases, many carry employer coverage beyond 65.

This is where the rules become far less clear.

Here’s what you need to know about coverage when working past age 65:

1. Employer size matters — a lot.

Medicare coordinates differently depending on whether your employer has more than 20 employees.  

With smaller employers, Medicare may become primary the month you turn 65. That means if you don’t enroll in Part B, you could end up uninsured for outpatient care — even though you have employer insurance.

Most people have no idea this rule exists, and they assume their employer plan protects them, resulting in unexpected medical bills.

The good news is now you know and can plan accordingly!

2. Not all employer plans are “creditable coverage.”

For Medicare to let you delay Part B or Part D without penalty, your employer plan must be considered creditable coverage, meaning it’s at least as good as Medicare’s baseline coverage.

This can only be confirmed with a letter from your employer or HR department.

If the plan is not creditable:

• Part B penalties can accumulate

• Part D penalties can accumulate

• You may have gaps in drug coverage

• You may face delayed Medicare enrollment windows

Many retirees assume their employer plan is creditable simply because it’s “good insurance.” That’s not always the case.

3. If you’re on a spouse’s employer plan, the rules shift again.

Being on your spouse’s plan means you must consider:

• Your spouse’s employer size

• Whether that employer considers dependents as having creditable coverage

• Whether your spouse plans to continue working

• Whether the plan allows you to stay on once your spouse retires

It’s very common for someone turning 65 to stay on a spouse’s plan without knowing they just triggered:

• Part B late enrollment penalties

• Loss of HSA eligibility

• A future coverage gap

These situations are avoidable — but only with guidance and preparation.

4. HSA contributions must stop when Medicare begins.

Many people continue contributing to an HSA without realizing:

• Once you enroll in Medicare (even just Part A), you must stop HSA contributions.

• If Medicare starts earlier than you expected, which is common, you may have to pay taxes on any HSA money you put in after your Medicare start date.

People who want to delay Medicare to keep contributing to an HSA must follow very specific timing rules.  

5. Medicare and employer insurance each have rules about who pays first.

If Medicare expects to be your primary coverage, but you never signed up for Part B, your employer insurance may deny claims because Medicare should have paid first.

This is how people unintentionally end up with:

• Unexpected bills

• Denied claims

• Costly out‑of‑pocket surprises

This usually doesn’t show up until a major medical event which is the worst possible time to discover a mistake.  

As you can see, these are complicated situations. That is why we recommend meeting with a Sams/Hockaday agent ahead of turning 65. You both will have the chance to ask all the right questions and get a solid plan in place for a smooth transition into age 65.

6. Drug coverage (Medicare Part D) must be evaluated separately.

Even if your employer medical coverage is creditable, your prescription coverage may not be.

Part D drug penalties accumulate if:

• Your drug coverage is not creditable

• You go 63 days or more without qualifying drug coverage

• You mistakenly assume your employer plan covers prescriptions as well as Medicare requires it to cover prescriptions

This is why reviewing prescription benefits is just as important as reviewing medical benefits.

Why This All Matters

When these rules aren’t followed correctly, people can end up with:

• Part B late enrollment penalties (which last for life)

• Part D late enrollment penalties (which also last for life)

• Coverage gaps during transitions

• Tax problems from HSA contributions

• Unpaid or denied claims from incorrect coordination

• Unexpected medical bills

• Delayed access to coverage when you need it most

And unfortunately, many retirees don’t realize there’s a problem until a claim is denied — often during a major health event.

More about the parts of Medicare on our website here.

Conclusion: A Quick Consultation Can Prevent Years of Issues

The good news? A short conversation with a local advisor who understands these rules can prevent all of the above.

At Sams/Hockaday, we regularly help retirees:

• Confirm whether their employer or spouse’s plan is creditable

• Understand whether they can safely delay Part B

• Avoid tax issues with HSAs

• Coordinate timelines between Medicare and employer coverage

• Avoid permanent penalties

• Transition smoothly when they retire

• Understand who pays first and why

It’s much easier to handle these decisions before you run into a problem — not after.

Sams/Hockaday & Associates, Inc.

217-423-8000

Samshockaday.com

‍